Inside the Hidden Market: Off-Market Properties Explained [Part 1]

One of the most common questions we receive from prospective clients is "Can you find me an off-market property?" Whilst yes, this is part of what we do, off-markets are not always the magical unicorns people imagine them to be. There are numerous things a buyer should know about how they work, and the perks and pitfalls associated with negotiating off-market. In this series, we will break down everything a buyer should know about off-market properties.

‍

Part 1: Understanding Off-Market Properties

What Is an Off-Market Property?

An off-market property is one that’s for sale, but not advertised publicly. Instead of running a full marketing campaign, the selling agent or seller approaches selected buyers directly — often from their existing database or professional network.

While off-market sales were once associated with urgent or distressed situations, they’re now common across a range of property types and price points.

‍

Types of Off-Markets

Direct-to-Buyer: The seller approaches a buyer privately, without using an agent or public advertising.

Agent-Introduced: The agent shares the property directly with select buyers from their database, with no public listing anywhere.

Quietly Advertised: The property appears only on the agency’s own website or social media, but not on major listing platforms like realestate.com.au or Domain.

‍

Why Sellers Choose to Sell Off-Market

From a seller’s perspective, there are a few practical reasons to take this approach:

Privacy and Discretion: Some sellers prefer to avoid open homes, public exposure, or speculation about their reasons for selling.

Testing the Market: Vendors who are uncertain about timing or price can gauge buyer interest without the commitment of a public launch.

Targeted Selling: Agents can approach qualified, motivated buyers directly — often speeding up the process.

Reducing Costs: A traditional marketing campaign can be expensive. Off-market sales can reduce those outlays significantly.

‍

What This Means for Buyers

Understanding why a property is sold off-market helps buyers better interpret the seller’s motivations. Unlike traditional sales, where marketing and competition signal urgency, off-market sales require more nuance. For instance, a seller “testing the waters” may not be eager to sell immediately but is gauging interest. In these cases, a reasonable, well-presented offer may encourage a sale, but unless the offer is truly stands out, some sellers may still prefer to wait for a public listing.

Sellers seeking privacy prefer a smooth, discreet process and may negotiate quickly if the buyer is serious and financially prepared. Pre-approval and flexibility on settlement can help.

Sometimes, an off-market sale is part of a strategic approach, with agents testing pricing or having interested buyers in their database. In such cases, prompt action and good communication with agents are key. Recognising these dynamics allows buyers to tailor their approach, build better agent relationships, and increase chances for future off-market opportunities.

‍

A Different Path to the Same Goal

Off-market sales aren’t inherently better or worse than public listings — they’re simply a different method of bringing buyers and sellers together. For some, they represent a way to avoid competition; for others, they’re a sign of opportunity missed if you’re not in the right networks.

In the next part of this series, we’ll look more closely at the advantages and drawbacks of buying off-market, and what to consider before pursuing this path.

If you’re looking to buy in the Sutherland Shire or southern Sydney, let’s chat. Your property journey deserves a partner who knows the path—and how to navigate it wisely.

‍

📞 Book your free consultation with My Property Pro today. Let us help you make it yours.

‍

‍