Sydney Property Market 2025: Sutherland Shire Trends

Published:     
July 28, 2025
by:
Andrew Hancock

The Australian property market has been on a roller-coaster over the past few years, marked by record-breaking price booms, a sudden cooling, and a recent cautious optimism. For first-home buyers and luxury upsizers (those eyeing $2 million+ homes) in Sydney’s southern suburbs, understanding these trends is crucial to making smart moves. In this comprehensive analysis, we’ll break down the latest market trends, regional insights for Sydney and the Sutherland Shire, and what they mean for buyers and sellers in 2025. We’ll also link to in-depth articles (our cluster posts) for further reading on specific topics. Let’s dive in.

‍

A Wild Ride: From Pandemic Boom to Interest Rate Squeeze

In the wake of the pandemic, Australia saw an unprecedented housing boom. Nationwide home values surged 38.4% from 2020 to 2022, far outpacing wage growth. Sydney and Melbourne led this charge with double-digit annual growth, pushing prices to all-time highs. By early 2022, Sydney’s median house price had reached a peak (around $1.6 million) amid frenzied demand and cheap credit. However, this euphoria set the stage for a sharp correction as economic conditions shifted.

What changed? In short, interest rates. The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) moved aggressively from mid-2022 to combat rising inflation, ending the era of record-low rates. After 13 consecutive rate hikes between May 2022 and November 2023, the cash rate skyrocketed from just 0.1% to 4.35%, a level not seen in over a decade. Borrowing costs jumped, monthly mortgage payments swelled, and buyers’ borrowing power shrank dramatically. The impact on the housing market was swift: buyer demand cooled and prices in overheated markets started to dip.

By late 2022 into 2023, previously roaring markets like Sydney and Melbourne entered a decline. Nationwide, housing values fell by roughly 5% from their peak by early 2023. Sydney’s high-end suburbs were among the hardest hit, as affordability was stretched to its limits. Many households with recent large mortgages felt the pinch of rising repayments, and buyer competition eased. Homes that once sold above asking were now receiving fewer bids, and auction clearance rates in Sydney plunged from the 70%-plus frenzy of 2021 to nearer 50-60% during the 2022 slowdown. In our article “Where Is the Property Market Heading in 2023?”, published at the start of that year, we predicted this broader market softening as interest rates rose and cost-of-living pressures mounted. Indeed, those forecasts played out: 2023 began with hesitancy and price declines in many areas.

However, the downturn wasn’t a freefall, and by mid-2023 a twist emerged. Australia’s housing market showed resilience. Despite higher rates, pent-up demand and limited supply put a floor under prices. CoreLogic data showed a “surprise turnaround” in the second half of 2023, with home values recovering and returning near their peak levels by year-end. Sydney led this rebound – after an approx. 13% drop from its early-2022 peak, values climbed back up through 2023, essentially erasing much of the decline. By early 2024, Sydney prices were flirting with new record highs. This resilience was attributed to strong employment, high immigration fueling demand, and buyers adjusting to the “new normal” of higher interest rates.

Market Cooling and Buying Opportunities in 2024

Despite the late-2023 rebound, the heat of the boom was gone – the market dynamic had clearly shifted from rampant seller’s market to a more balanced state. As 2024 unfolded, caution and realism became the dominant themes. Higher interest rates continued to bite, and many buyers remained price-sensitive. One emerging trend we observed as buyer’s agents was properties selling below their listed guide prices, which we covered in our article “Why More Properties Are Selling Below the Guide Price in Today’s Market.” This was almost unheard of during the boom, but by 2024 it became increasingly common to see homes adjust down to meet the market. In fact, we saw numerous listings in Sydney’s south where the asking price had to be cut multiple times before finding a buyer .

What caused this cooling? Several factors converged:

  • Market Correction of Overvalued Prices: After the dizzying 20-30% jumps in 2021, some degree of price correction was natural. Many buyers simply could no longer afford peak prices, especially with higher loan costs, so prices in some areas had to adjust down to realistic levels.

  • Interest Rate Stall at High Levels: By late 2023, the RBA had paused hikes but kept rates high (above 4%). This stagnation of rates at high levels sapped buyer enthusiasm. Would-be buyers either hit borrowing limits or adopted a wait-and-see approach, anticipating that if they held off, sellers might drop prices further.

  • Increased Stock and Choice: Unlike 2021 when listings were scarce, by 2024 many markets saw a surge in available listings. In Sydney and especially the Sutherland Shire, we noticed more properties coming to market as some owners tried to time the peak or offload investments. With more choices, buyers became picky, often bypassing properties perceived as overpriced. Homes with flaws or in less prime locations had to reduce prices to attract interest.

  • Cost of Living Squeeze: Broader economic pressures (inflation in energy, food, etc.) made buyers more budget-conscious. First-home buyers were particularly affected, as rising rents and living costs ate into their saving capacity. Affordability concerns meant fewer bidding wars and more careful offers.

All of this meant that by late 2024, we entered a phase best described as a buyer’s market in many areas. Homes that were unrealistically priced stagnated on the market. Sellers who were willing to meet the market (by setting a fair guide price or accepting a reasonable offer) still sold, but those holding out for 2021-level prices often saw their listings languish. Properties started transacting at or below their guide prices, which presented opportunities for savvy buyers. According to real estate data, Sydney’s median days on market stretched to 48 days (up from 38 days a year prior) by early 2025 – a clear sign that homes were taking longer to sell and buyers were negotiating harder.

For buyers, this cooling was actually welcome news. If you had felt priced out during the boom, the period of 2023–2024 offered a chance to get back in the game without needing to wildly outbid others. In fact, negotiation power shifted slightly towards buyers. We advised our clients in this period to seize the moment: when a quality property’s price guide was trimmed, it could be the perfect time to make a move (provided you’ve done your due diligence on the asset). As we noted in our guide to the cooling market, buyers could “find more negotiating power and potentially score a better deal” in these conditions. It bears remembering though – a “cheap” property isn’t a good deal unless it’s the right property. We always emphasize focusing on value: a solid home in a high-demand area at a fair price is a great buy, whereas an unreliable property is not a bargain at any price.

From the seller’s perspective, the cooling market was challenging. Many sellers had to reset their price expectations to align with the new reality. In hot markets, sellers could name almost any price and find a willing buyer. Not so in 2024. We wrote about this in “Navigating Seller Expectations: Insights from a Buyer’s Agent,” where we highlighted cases of sellers stubbornly clinging to outdated price ideas and ultimately missing out on good offers. For instance, in one Shire case, a seller rejected a strong offer of $1.88M (backed by solid comparable sales data) because they “would not accept anything below $1.9M.” They even raised their asking to $2M mid-negotiation – only to see the buyer walk away and purchase elsewhere. A week later, facing reality, the seller agreed to $1.88M, but by then the opportunity was gone. The home failed to sell at auction and remained on the market unsold. This kind of outcome became more frequent as the market cooled. Sellers who adapted quickly – by pricing correctly, listening to market feedback, and adjusting – were still able to sell relatively smoothly. Those who didn’t ended up chasing the market down or sitting on unsold properties. The lesson? Whether buying or selling, real-time market data and a realistic mindset are your best allies.

Sydney’s Southern Suburbs: Sutherland Shire Market Resilience

Now, let’s zoom into Sydney, and specifically the southern suburbs (Sutherland Shire) – our specialty and a region of keen interest for many readers. How did the Shire fare amid these national trends? In a word: resilience. While Sydney overall saw moderate price drops in 2022 followed by a rebound, the Sutherland Shire stayed relatively stable and strong throughout. As of December 2023, the Shire’s median house price was about $1.93 million, just 2% lower than a year earlier (it was $1.97M in Dec 2022). In other words, a minor dip. Units in the Shire actually rose ~1.7% in the same 12 months (from $1.22M to $1.24M). This essentially flat performance (-2% to +1.7%) over 2023 stands in contrast to some other Sydney regions that saw larger swings.

Why has the Sutherland Shire been so steady? A few key reasons:

  • Limited Supply, High Demand: The Shire is geographically blessed (and constrained) – wedged between beautiful beaches, bays, and national parks, there’s little room for new sprawling developments. No big new estates are popping up to flood supply. The suburbs here are also “tightly held” – people love living in the Shire and don’t sell often. This naturally props up prices. Even when the broader market wobbles, the Shire’s low inventory prevents any glut. At the same time, demand remains strong: families are drawn to the area’s lifestyle (surf at Cronulla, bushwalk in Royal National Park) and locals often want to stay local (young people leaving home tend to try to buy nearby). This dynamic of lots of buyers vs. few sellers kept a floor under Shire prices even as interest rates rose.

  • Desirable Lifestyle and Amenities: Beyond pure numbers, the Sutherland Shire offers an enviable lifestyle – a coastal vibe with city access. During the pandemic boom, areas like the Shire benefited as people valued space and lifestyle, a trend that hasn’t fully reversed. Features like good schools, community spirit, and relative affordability compared to the Eastern Suburbs or North Shore make the Shire perpetually popular. This intrinsic appeal means there’s usually a buyer ready, even if at a slightly adjusted price.

  • Rental Market Boom: Another factor has been the rental market, which exploded in recent years. Investors have noticed that while Shire property prices stayed stable, rents have climbed to record highs. The median house rent in the Shire hit about $782/week (up 6.2% in 12 months) by late 2023, and units around $603/week (+4.4% annually). These are the highest rents ever in the area, translating to improved rental yields for investors. With vacancy rates an incredibly low 0.8%, virtually every rental gets snapped up. For property owners, this means holding costs are cushioned by better yields, so there’s less pressure to fire-sell. And for would-be first-home buyers, tight rentals often nudge them to buy if they can, sustaining buyer demand.

All told, the Sutherland Shire has been one of Sydney’s most robust markets through the turbulence. As local buyer’s agents, we often reassure clients that buying in the Shire is a sound long-term bet. Historical data backs this up: the Shire’s average annual price growth is about 6.9% for houses and 7.3% for units (10-year hold period) – strong compounding growth that outpaces many other investments. Even after the recent ups and downs, most homeowners in the Shire have substantial equity gains over the past decade.

For first-home buyers, the cooling of late 2022–2023 has actually been something of a breather in the Shire. Earlier, many felt completely priced out of their own hometown. During the 2021 boom, it seemed impossible to find a house under $1.5M as competition was fierce. But with the market “cooling down slightly, it’s now the perfect time to jump back in and secure that dream home” in the Shire, as one local real estate update put it. Indeed, throughout 2023 we saw more affordable buying opportunities emerge – from motivated sellers, properties that needed a little TLC, or simply less frenzied auction rooms. We’ve helped several young families finally buy in the Shire after they had been outbid multiple times in 2021. Their feedback is often that the process felt less stressful in the cooler market: they could negotiate and include proper due diligence clauses instead of having to waive everything just to compete.

For upgraders looking in the $2M+ range, the Shire still offers relative “bang for buck”. With ~$2 million to spend, buyers can target premium suburbs (waterfront homes in Como or Burraneer, for example, or large family homes in Caringbah South) that would cost far more in other parts of Sydney. During the recent market lull, some high-end properties in the Shire were quietly selling for below their initial price guides, meaning prestige buyers could occasionally snag a deal. However, note that truly top-tier properties (think absolute waterfront or architect-designed luxury homes) in the Shire remain tightly held and often still attract competition when they do hit the market – quality always has a market.

In summary, Sydney’s southern suburbs have largely held their value through the storm. As the broader market regains momentum in 2025, the Shire is well placed to lead the upswing, given its strong fundamentals. For anyone looking to buy in this area, the key is to stay informed on micro-market trends (each suburb can vary – e.g., Gymea Bay’s median rose +0.6% last year while nearby Sylvania’s fell -4.4%. Target the suburbs that match your lifestyle and budget, and be ready to act when the right opportunity appears.

The “Beachside Blues”: Cautionary Tale of Holiday Homes

A discussion of property trends wouldn’t be complete without addressing a particular post-pandemic trend: the love affair with lifestyle properties. The urge to buy a holiday house by the beach gripped many Australians recently – especially after lockdowns, who didn’t dream of a coastal escape to call their own? Beachside and regional holiday towns saw a surge of interest and price growth in 2020-2021 (Byron Bay, anyone?). However, buyers should tread carefully: investing in a holiday home is not all sunshine and ice cream. In our article “The Beach-Side Blues,” we explored why mixing property investment with a bit of vacation fantasy can backfire.

Here are some insights if you’re considering that cute cottage by the coast as your next purchase:

  • Weaker Long-Term Growth Drivers: Vacation towns often lack the economic fundamentals that drive sustained property growth. Major employment hubs, infrastructure projects, and year-round population growth are typically limited in small coastal towns. Over a full market cycle, a house in a sleepy beach town may appreciate far less than a house in a thriving metropolitan suburb. For example, during the Global Financial Crisis, Noosa Heads – a popular holiday locale – saw its median house price plunge from about $785,000 in 2008 to $590,000 by 2011, and even a decade later it was still tens of thousands below its pre-GFC high. Meanwhile, many Sydney suburbs were hitting new highs. This illustrates that when downturns hit, lifestyle markets can be hit harder and take far longer to recover.

  • First to Fall in a Downturn: Holiday areas heavily dependent on tourism are often the first to feel pain in economic downturns. When people tighten their belts, discretionary travel is cut and demand for holiday rentals drops. Owners of holiday homes might be forced to slash rents or face long vacancies. In severe downturns, investors often offload second homes (which are non-essential) before selling their primary residence. If many do this at once, it floods the local market and drives prices down quickly. In contrast, primary residence markets (like Sydney) tend to be more “inelastic” – people always need a place to live, so those markets have more built-in support.

  • Rental Volatility and Carrying Costs: Unlike a city investment unit that can find tenants year-round, a beach house might only be in demand during peak summer. The seasonal nature of demand means you could have a high vacancy for months. And if you intend to use it yourself on weekends, that’s time it’s not producing income – plus it limits tax deductions (since it’s not available for rent when you use it). Don’t forget maintenance: salt air, for instance, can wreak havoc causing higher upkeep costs. When you do the math, many people find it’s actually cheaper to rent a holiday home for the few weeks you use it, rather than owning one year-round.

Now, that’s not to pour cold water on everyone’s beach house dreams! For some, a holiday home is a lifestyle choice and a reward for hard work, and that’s fine if you’re financially secure. But the Beachside Blues analysis urges separating emotional purchases from investment decisions. If your primary goal is investment growth or income, you’re usually better off buying in a fundamentally strong location (good yield, strong population growth, diverse economy) rather than trying to mix investment with leisure. As we concluded, chasing an emotional purchase can lead to “unnecessary risk” and potentially lower returns. On the flip side, by making “unemotional, well-researched decisions in fundamentally sound locations,” you’re likely to end up with more wealth – wealth that can fund plenty of beach vacations wherever you want.

Bottom line: The Australian market offers many tempting opportunities, from coastal getaways to rural retreats, but always do your homework. The current trend shows regional markets had spectacular runs (some up 40-60% since 2020) but are now leveling off. It’s a great time to review your investment strategy – ensure your portfolio isn’t over-exposed to one type of area and that each property serves a clear purpose (either yield, growth, or lifestyle – but ideally not all at once).

Bridging the Buyer-Seller Expectation Gap

One of the most striking recent trends – especially in our Sydney markets – has been the growing gap between buyer and seller expectations. Even as data showed a cooler market, many sellers remained anchored to yesterday’s sky-high prices. This created a perplexing situation: well-informed buyers would make solid offers supported by market evidence, only for sellers to reject them and hold out for more. Why the stalemate?

Our cluster article “Navigating Seller Expectations: Insights from a Buyer’s Agent” delved into this. The causes include emotional attachment (it’s hard for an owner to accept that their beloved home isn’t worth what they think) and market misconceptions (some sellers still quote last year’s boom headlines or a neighbor’s record price, even if conditions have changed). There’s also an element of regret aversion – the fear of selling “too low” and regretting it later makes some hold out unrealistically. In certain cases, even real estate agents can inadvertently inflate expectations, either by over-quoting to win a listing or encouraging a seller to push higher (when the agent may actually know the offer on the table is fair). All this results in properties that don’t sell as quickly, and missed opportunities for both sides.

For buyers, dealing with such sellers requires patience and strategy. First, educate yourself on true market value – if you have comparable sales data and perhaps a buyer’s agent advising you, you’ll know a reasonable price range for a property. This helps you confidently make an offer and stick to your limit. Second, be prepared to walk away if the seller is in la-la land. As we often remind clients, there will be other opportunities, and it’s better to miss a purchase than to overpay severely. Interestingly, we’ve seen multiple cases where our clients’ offers were initially rejected, only for the seller to come back weeks later willing to accept – sometimes after an auction fails or no better offers emerge. By that time, our clients had often moved on or bought elsewhere (as in the $1.88M story above). So, buyers should also keep the door open: maintain polite communication with the selling agent even if negotiations stall. Let them know your offer still stands (if it does) and you’re open to talk. We’ve had situations where a deal was resurrected because we signaled continued interest professionally.

For sellers, the current trend is a caution: price realistically from the start. The data shows that properties priced correctly (in line with recent comparable sales, not last year’s peak) attract more buyers and sell faster. Those that start too high end up sitting on the market, often requiring price reductions that exceed what the initial correct price would have been. As we advised in the Guide to Seller Expectations, get appraisals backed by hard data and don’t simply choose the highest quote agent. A good agent will tell you the truth, even if it’s not what you want to hear – that honesty will save you time and money in the long run.

The encouraging news is that as 2025 unfolds, this expectation gap may narrow. With the market picking up again, many sellers are gaining confidence to list, and buyers are coming back out in force. Fresh sales results (especially if they’re strong) will help recalibrate everyone’s sense of value. Already, Sydney’s auction clearance rates have climbed back into the 70%+ range in early 2025, indicating more alignment between what buyers will pay and sellers will accept. In plain terms, properties are meeting their reserve prices more often, which suggests better pricing strategies and realistic negotiation on both ends. This equilibrium is healthy – it greases the wheels of the market.

Looking Ahead: 2025 and Beyond

After a turbulent few years, what’s next for the Australian property market? Many experts foresee moderate growth ahead, rather than another runaway boom. A recent Reuters survey of analysts projected about +3.7% price growth for 2025 nationally, with slightly higher gains (5% annual) in 2026 and 2027. In other words, a steady climb rather than a rocket. This is supported by the expectation of minor interest rate relief: the RBA delivered its first rate cuts in early 2025 (down to 3.85% in May) and could trim a bit further. Lower rates typically stimulate buyer demand. Indeed, Sydney is once again on the rise in 2025, with the February rate cut “resulting in a rapid turnaround” in buyer activity. By mid-2025, Sydney’s dwelling values hit fresh record highs, and prices are trending up again after the 2024 pause. Auction crowds have grown, and open-home attendance is buzzing in the Shire and beyond.

That said, don’t expect 20% annual jumps – the era of cheap money is over, and affordability remains a pressing issue. As one investment bank strategist noted, “You have to be middle-aged and above-average earning to enter the housing market” in much of Australia. Housing affordability (price-to-income ratios, etc.) is stretched, and governments are under pressure to address supply shortages. These factors will likely keep a lid on excessive price growth. Many homeowners are also constrained by how much they can upgrade, given their existing mortgage and new lending standards. All this points to growth, but at a sustainable pace.

For first-home buyers, 2025 could actually be one of the better windows in recent times. Prices in Sydney are high, yes, but government incentives (like first-home buyer grants or stamp duty concessions) are being expanded in NSW to help new entrants. Plus, the biggest hurdle – saving a deposit – gets slightly easier if prices aren’t sprinting away every month. We also see an interesting trend: unit apartments have become hot property for first-home buyers and investors alike. Sydney’s unit values climbed only +0.7% in the past year (much less than houses), making units a comparatively affordable entry point. With rental vacancy so low, buying a unit to live in (or even rent out) can beat paying exorbitant rent. Immigration is also boosting unit demand – new arrivals often rent or buy apartments – which underpins values. So if you’re a first-timer, don’t be afraid to consider a unit or townhouse as your stepping stone into the market.

For those looking to upgrade to a luxury home, keep an eye on the upper-end listings in suburbs like Burraneer, Dolans Bay, or Kangaroo Point (which incidentally was up +2.7% last year). High-end segments sometimes move a bit differently; they cooled in 2022 more than mid-range homes, but they’re also often first to bounce back when confidence returns. In 2025, with the sharemarket recovering and businesses doing well, some cashed-up buyers are back in play for prestige homes. We’ve observed a few $3M+ sales recently in the Shire that set benchmark prices, reflecting renewed confidence. If you’re upgrading, you might face more competition as the year progresses, so early in the upswing (like now) could be a strategic time to make your move before prices potentially climb further. Always ensure you have your current home’s sale or equity sorted (we advise consulting on whether to buy or sell first based on your situation – each has pros and cons).

In conclusion, the Australian property market’s latest trends show strong underlying resilience and a return to a more “normal” trajectory of growth following extreme volatility. Sydney’s southern suburbs exemplify this resilience, maintaining value and seeing loyal demand even in tougher times. While challenges like affordability and interest rates persist, opportunities abound for those who stay informed and decisive. Data and expert insights are your friend – whether it’s knowing that a certain suburb’s prices are dipping (time to pounce) or understanding that a seller’s sky-high price will likely come down (time to be patient), having the right knowledge gives you an edge.

Remember: property is typically a long game. Over the past 5 years, Sydney home values are up 34% and over 10 years up 56% – despite all the intervening crises and corrections. Real estate remains one of the most reliable ways to build wealth in Australia, if you buy smart. So equip yourself with the latest market analysis (like you’re doing now), lean on professionals for guidance when needed, and be ready to act. The team at MyPropertyPro is here to help – as Sutherland Shire and Sydney Southern Suburbs specialists, we offer personalized assistance to navigate these trends and secure the best property for your needs. The market is moving – time to make your move too!

Sources Used: